Monday, 27 January 2014

Welsh Rugby is Contracting - It's Official

I am ashamed to admit that I took one look at the weather and I decided not to go to Bonymaen to watch the Pooler. Instead I reclined on the couch and flicked between watching the Dragons v Northampton and Racing v Toulouse whilst paying attention to the twitter feed from Ken Long who was braving the elements in Bonymaen. In the end, Pooler lost a close match 10-8 with the stormy conditions having a large influence on the result.
The Dragons’ match was not close at all and it was a salutary lesson for those who think that the Welsh regions could breeze into the English Premiership. Make no mistake, this was Northampton seconds who brushed most of the Dragons’ first team aside.
In France, I thought that the Welsh representatives in the Racing team acquitted themselves well and were all fully committed despite the first Six Nations game being only a week away. Mike Phillips was particularly prominent and at his spiky best. I assume the Welsh based members of the Welsh squad all had their feet up somewhere. I guess this is the harsh reality of playing in France.
So Sam Warburton is the first Welsh centrally contracted player - let’s hope that he is not the last! I don’t think it makes much sense having a small number and at the very least it should be two per region. Can the WRU afford this? Even at around quarter of a million pounds per player the WRU are still far short of Leigh Halfpenny’s reported deal in France and what I suppose George North got from Northampton. Are we wasting money battling against market forces when our pockets are not really deep enough I wonder? The whole subject of centrally funding players begs a lot of questions and we haven’t really been party to the WRU’s thinking yet. Who decides who is centrally contracted, how much they are paid and who they play for?
Of course, centrally funding one player hasn’t really solved any of the underlying issues that are tormenting Welsh rugby but at least it might be viewed as a statement of intent from the WRU. I watched last week’s Scrum V Special with a mixture of sadness and disbelief. It seems hard to imagine the issues being solved by those on view who seem content to waffle on without actually saying (or doing) anything. And then there was David Moffett who seems to want to throw his hat in the ring. His interpersonal skills will certainly not pour oil on stormy waters. What a mess!
We should be looking forward with eager anticipation to the Six Nations but somehow the political wrangling seems to still have centre stage. Perhaps they all hope that it will all go away like magic once we kick off against Italy. I have got news for them - it will not.

The one down side of the Six Nations is the lack of club rugby. Only one game scheduled for the Pooler in February - why?

Sunday, 19 January 2014

Welsh Rugby Top Ten

Unfortunately the Pontypool v Llanharan game was rained off and so I turned to musing about Welsh rugby’s current mess. It’s quite sad really but I came up with this list of songs that sum up the situation as I see it:

1.         We don’t talk any more                                  Cliff Richard
2.         Money’s too tight to mention                           Simply Red
3.         Breakaway                                                    The Beach Boys
4.         I guess that’s why they call it the blues            Elton John
5.         Euros to me are everything                             The Real Thing
6.         These boots are made for walking                   Nancy Sinatra
7.         Lost in France (or finance)                              Bonnie Tyler
8.         Come back and stay                                      Paul Young
9.         If you leave me now                                        Chicago
10.       With or without you                                         U2

Close contenders are “Help” by the Beatles and “All I need is a miracle” by Mike and the Mechanics. I am sure that you can think of plenty of others.

I did watch a bit of the Heineken Cup on the TV and it is interesting to note that none of the current Welsh squad will be playing in the quarter finals.


Let’s hope the sun shines next weekend or I’ll be thinking of a top ten of films! 

Monday, 13 January 2014

Quick on the Draw

I had been away on holiday to grab some Winter sun and had missed the last two Pontypool games so I was in urgent need of a rugby fix as we headed for Bridgend Athletic. Recent games have been close affairs with the outcome still in the balance in the last few minutes so this was going to be a stern test for Pooler after their narrow defeat at home to Newbridge in the Cup last week.
The game was played in glorious sunny conditions but on a sticky pitch that had suffered from the ravages of the recent bad weather. The game was a really scrappy affair, littered with mistakes, with neither side able to achieve any measure of control for a significant period. Bridgend Athletic probably edged the first half in terms of territory and possession and deserved their 6-3 interval lead.
The second half was a little better with an early exchange of penalties taking the score to 9-6. Pooler scrum half Quick then had a clearance kick charged down by his opposite number who won the chase for the ball to score the first try of the game. The conversion was missed but a 14-6 lead in the context of this game looked pretty significant. To their credit, Pooler upped their game and responded with a penalty before Quick atoned for his earlier mistake by scoring try in the corner from an attacking scrum. Mills narrowly missed the conversion so the score was tied at 14-14 as the game entered the final quarter of an hour. The home side came back strongly but could not breach a determined Pooler defence. Pooler had a glorious chance to pinch the game with the last play of the game but Norton knocked on with line at his mercy.
A draw was probably a fair result at the end of the game as neither side really did enough to win. It was a good job that the game was relatively low scoring as there was no scoreboard and there weren’t any announcements!
I had hoped that when I came back from my holiday that the row in Welsh rugby between the WRU and the Regions would have been settled. Surprise, surprise the situation has deteriorated, if anything, with ultimata coming and going and much vitriol. A further surprise came when I heard David Moffett being interviewed on the radio. He wants to be the white knight who is going to come all the way from the Antipodes to sort Welsh (and European) rugby out. It puts me in mind of a Bonny Tyler song! I guess he would then move on to design an economic nuclear fusion reactor. The one thing in his favour is that he will speak his mind and might knock a few heads together but I thought that we had managed to get rid of him. I thought that ultimately the clubs ran Welsh rugby through the WRU. Is no one interested in what the smaller clubs think? In the real world, I think that a CEO would be more than a little concerned about his position if he presided over a debacle of this magnitude 
Quite simply the Welsh Regions have not got enough money or resources to compete at Heineken Cup level. Yes the players that they can afford can raise their games every now and then to gain an excellent victory. To do that for six games in the qualification stages, however, is beyond them as this season’s competition has demonstrated yet again. If it was a straight knock-out competition from the star, we might have a better chance. What the Heineken Cup is doing for us is accelerating the development of young players who just have to be thrown in at the deep end as the injuries to the senior players mount from squads already depleted by defections to France and England. This certainly has benefits for the national team but there is no prospect of a Welsh Region winning the Heineken Cup. Standing on the Bank in Pontypool, I wonder if it matters.


Happy New Year.

Saturday, 21 December 2013

The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

The good news is that Pontypool recorded a hard fought victory over Tata Steel on a cold, grey and windy afternoon at Pontypool Park.
Pooler got off to a fast start playing down the slope when lock Jones crossed after some good interplay by the backs and forwards. There was a strong cross wind that made kicking difficult to judge and the try went unconverted. The home team continued to press and increased their lead when, following a lineout on the visitor’s 22 metre line, Norton took a well-timed pass by Mills at pace to slice through and score without a hand being laid on him. The successful conversion gave Pooler a handy 12-0 lead. Tata stormed back and showed that they had plenty of pace in their back line but it was the power of their pack that paved the way for an unconverted try. Pooler almost immediately responded when loose head prop Prosser scored a try after an attempted relieving kick was charged down near the away team’s line. The successful conversion increased the lead to 19-5. The last score of an entertaining first half was a penalty for Tata that closed the gap to 19-8.
In the second half, Tata emerged with real purpose and began to dominate possession and territory with their scrum getting on top. They hammered away at the Pooler line for about 15 minutes but the home defence somehow managed to keep them out. Very much against the run of play, Pooler managed to escape from their 22 for Mills to kick a penalty and increase the lead to 22-8. The play returned to the Pooler 22 but Tata still couldn’t manage to cross the line despite their best efforts. It was left to Taylor to hammer the final nail in the coffin when he scored Pooler’s bonus point try after a kick and chase.
This was another gutsy performance from Pontypool who once again took their chances and scrambled well in defence. Hopefully the team will continue to develop and we can look forward to a successful new year and a top three finish in the Championship.


So on to the bad and the ugly but I will let you choose whether it is the WRU or the Welsh regional rugby teams that are bad and ugly.
So the Welsh regions have finally realised that Welsh rugby needs to be saved. They didn’t seem to be the least bothered when the WRU funding of the smaller clubs spiralled downwards as they frittered away money on second rate overseas players rather than helping the clubs any distance away from the M4 to develop their own. A lot of people warned that the roots of the game in Wales were being irreparably damaged in large swathes of the country as they were starved of funds. Small wonder that, after a while, the other parts of the tree are feeling the effect. If we are not careful the whole lot will collapse and have a major negative impact on the national team.
We currently seem to have just enough high class players to be competitive at test level in Europe but it wouldn’t take too many injuries before we would start to struggle. The exodus of our top players to France and England will surely lead to more injuries as they are forced to play week in week out in a far tougher league than they are used to.
The regions have recently launched a Protect Our Game campaign but perhaps it should be Develop Our Game. This not only sounds more forward-looking but the acronym also sums up the performance of the regions as businesses.
The regional product has never really worked in Wales as the results in the Heineken Cup and the poor attendances at home games clearly seem to indicate. The Welsh are a parochial race and we like local derbys and the only time the regions get decent crowds is when the play other Welsh regions - perhaps there is clue there.
In order to be competitive we hear, the regions need even more money to spend on players’ wages. This of course will just serve to fuel the upward spiral of player wages in Europe and we will inevitably end up in the same position as we are now but paying higher wages to even more mediocre overseas players as we can surely not compete with the deep pockets in England and France for the best players. Since there is no extra money available something else would have to suffer and I don’t suppose it would be the wages of the WRU staff but more likely the clubs again.

So what can we do?
The regions answer seems to be to bully the WRU into submission by getting popular support for their demands and threatening to go and play in England. They even talk about getting politicians involved but this is surely the kiss of death for any campaign. Could the WRU just cast the regions adrift and let them play in England like our major soccer teams? If they did that what would be the impact on the national team? This of course means that the WRU relinquishes control of the top players but at least they wouldn’t have to subsidise their wages.
From the WRU perspective, there is talk of central contracts for a small number of key players to keep them in Wales but they will need to pay big bucks to be competitive - even Ireland could not persuade Sexton to stay when the French came calling. There therefore doesn’t seem to be any point in wasting even more money in this way particularly when the regions may not even give these players a game. Then there was the empty WRU threat to players that they would not be picked for Wales if they played outside Wales. It soon became clear that this was not practical as the exodus of players gathered pace.
If you add to this standoff the uncertainty surrounding the Heineken Cup then you indeed have a recipe for disaster. I think it was Richard Burton who said that if you put a Welshman in a room with a hundred doors he would leave through the only one marked self-destruct and he should know. So it is no surprise that it seems to be the way that Welsh rugby is heading.


What would I do? I think that I would bring in the highly developed interpersonal skills of Vincent Tan to sort things out

Sunday, 15 December 2013

Wind of Change

A visit to local rivals Newbridge is a good way to measure the progress that Pontypool have made this season. It has never been an easy place to get a positive result as Pooler found out last season when they were roundly trounced. We anticipated a fiercely contested local derby and were not disappointed.
Pontypool won the toss and elected to play with the strong breeze that was blowing up the valley. They started in a similar vein to the way that they played against Tondu with the backs looking sharp and wing James soon crossed in the corner for an excellent try. Mills converted expertly from the touch line and the away team took a 0-7 lead. As you would expect, Newbridge were stung into action and although they had plenty of possession the Pontypool defence looked strong and they were able to win turnovers and use the wind to send the home team back into their half. In the set pieces the Pooler scrum seemed to have the edge although the wind made the lineouts a bit of a lottery. From a scrum won against the head, Pontypool attacked at pace and after some incisive back play Thorley scored a try that was converted by Mills. Newbridge continued to have the lion’s share of possession but the away defence stood firm even when they were reduced to 14 men following the sin-binning of Organ. With the last play of the first half, the Pontypool backs had another chance to show what they could do and James crossed after some strong running from full back Taylor. The conversion failed but at half time Pontypool held a useful 0-19 lead. The first half had been an object lesson in clinical finishing.
The second half was a bad tempered affair and was dominated both in terms of territory and possession by Newbridge. The strong breeze of the first half increased in ferocity and the away side were pinned for long periods in their own half. Frustration frequently boiled over and the two scrum halves were yellow-carded for fighting before Pooler lock Davies was red-carded for rashly kicking out at an opponent. Newbridge turned their domination into points and scored three good tries but only converted one of them. This left the score at 17-19 and it looked more than likely that the rampant home side would take the spoils in the closing minutes. The weather had deteriorated with torrential rain in addition to the gale force wind blowing into the away team’s faces making it even more difficult for Pontypool to clear their lines. Somehow Pooler managed to hold on against all the odds in a desperate finish.
This was character-building stuff for Pontypool and no one can doubt their commitment and will to win but ill-discipline could so easily have cost them the match. A top three finish in the league would be an excellent outcome for the season and it should be possible if they can keep playing with this amount of heart and get the backs running at the opposition. Pooler have two home games coming up against Tata Steel and Beddau. Let’s hope we can finish 2013 in style.
There is a wind of change blowing through Welsh rugby but I am none the wiser of where it will take us. Part of me just wishes that the regions would go and play in England and let the WRU concentrate their efforts and money on the development of players through the traditional club structure in Wales. This would leave something like the situation with football but you really wouldn’t want the national rugby team to follow the path of the national football team. I just hope someone manages to sort something out soon as the Heineken Cup has again produced some great matches this weekend. 
Unfortunately unless the Blues can produce a minor miracle at Toulon, I fear the only Welsh interest in the latter stages of this season’s competition will be whether Nigel Owens referees the final and how many pints they sell in the Millennium Stadium in May.
On a positive note, there does still seem to be plenty of young talent playing for the regions and they are certainly being blooded as the established players emigrate. If only there was an under-21 Heineken Cup (perhaps the Shandy Cup!) we might have a chance of winning something.
Does anyone know if there is a rugby equivalent of ACAS or do we need to ask Tony Blair to sort it out?

  

Sunday, 8 December 2013

Normal Service Is Resumed

It was a joy to get away from the angst and over-analysis that characterises the Autumn internationals and return to normality. Normality in this case is watching Pontypool locking horns with Tondu at Pontypool Park. We didn’t have to worry whether our defence was blitz, drift, or scramble and fret about gain line success and tackle counts. Here we just had two sides going at each other with all out attacking intent and it was all the more enjoyable for that. The quality of the game was certainly improved by an excellent referee on an exchange visit from England who helped the game to flow. All too often in rugby these days the referee has the ability to kill a game as a spectacle.
Pooler playing up the slope started the match with attacking verve and looked set to blow Tondu away. They quickly established a 13 point lead through a well executed converted try and two penalties. The home half backs were controlling the game skilfully and it looked ominous for the visitors. As often happens though, Pooler relaxed and Tondu seized the opportunity to show what they could do. Whilst Pooler’s attacking threat came from the backs, for Tondu it was a strong driving maul. The second 20 minutes really belonged to the away side and they dominated territory and possession. It was no more than they deserved that they closed the gap to 3 points with a converted try and a penalty. With the score 13-10 at the end of an enjoyable first half, the result seemed to be very much in the balance.
The second half, however, turned out to be a pretty one-sided affair with Pontypool firmly in control. At times they played some scintillating rugby with Mills, having one of his best games for Pontypool, at the heart of things. Their most potent attacking weapon was the strong attacking thrusts by Taylor from full back who really was too hot for Tondu to handle. An early yellow card for Tondu seemed to give Pooler all the impetus they needed and they ran in three more converted tries and a penalty to run out convincing victors 40-10. Tondu never gave up and deserved something for their efforts but the home defence held firm despite some late pressure.
It was good to see Pontypool back to their best after a shaky period and let’s hope that they can carry it forward to next week when they take on the “Blue Pigs” of Newbridge in what is sure to be a tough local derby.
The Heineken Cup saga goes on and on and it now seems inevitable that it will be Welsh rugby that will suffer most. I cannot think for one moment that a court case will help anyone except perhaps the lawyers. It is almost unbelievable that the most successful club rugby tournament ever is likely to be grossly devalued next year by greed and pig-headedness. It’s a wonder that anyone would want to sponsor a rugby tournament going forward.
I haven’t seen much of the current round of Heineken Cup matches but I did catch a bit of Northampton v Leinster and it now seems quite obvious why the English teams want to avoid the Irish next year. The Irish players certainly look strong this season and I think I might put a few quid on them to win the Six Nations.

They say that Heineken reaches the parts that others don’t - what price Pooler representing Wales in the Heineken Cup next season? 

Sunday, 1 December 2013

North South Divide

So here we go again, it’s the next instalment in the long running soap opera that is Wales v Australia rugby matches - Neighbours meets Pobl Y Cwm. The one thing that we can be sure of is a cliffhanging ending. The only trouble is we always seem to be able to guess what the outcome will be no matter how they get to the edge of the cliff.
In truth, for most of this match, the two teams were poles apart with Australia decidedly superior. Fortunately Wales had the North Star to guide them and that kept them in the game. North’s long range try and a Halfpenny penalty gave them an unlikely lead in the opening exchanges even though they barely had the ball.
For the next hour it was all Australia as they turned a 10 point deficit to a 14 point lead. Sitting behind the posts, it was alarming to see how Cooper managed to orchestrate overlaps with ease. The Australians were certainly helped by some indifferent kicking from Wales plus a pretty ropey Welsh line out but they have classy backs who are always looking to offload. A combination of, at times, inspirational defence plus a few missed chances kept the deficit to 14 points. In truth it could have been a lot more although some would argue that it should actually have been less as the referee awarded Australia a try from what looked like a clear forward pass.
In the nature of this fixture, Wales were bound to come back and come back they did. Cue George North and he didn’t disappoint slicing through to score under the posts. The converted try and a penalty closed the gap to just 4 points and the momentum swung to Wales. Australia were reduced to 14 men by a yellow card and Wales pressed hard. Could Wales do a Southern Hemisphere and snatch victory from the jaws of defeat? You guessed the answer. Wales are not the All Blacks and lacked the precision and patience to set up a winning score and the score remained 26-30.
So yet another failure against one of the big three Southern Hemisphere teams. More hard luck stories and all those injuries too. It's the same old story when it comes down to it we are just not good enough.
Perhaps we just need a new script writer.

PS
Last week I was moaning about the scrums, well wasn’t it refreshing to watch a game with so few scrums. It’s almost like a different game.

No, I’m still not going to comment on the Heineken Cup debacle - at least not until I understand it (and that might take a while!)